 | Ben Stiller als Rabbi Jake Schram |
 | Edward Norton als Father Brian Finn |
 | Jenna Elfman als Anna Riley |
 | Anne Bancroft als Ruth Schram |
 | Eli Wallach als Rabbi Ben Lewis |
 | Ron Rifkin als Larry Friedman |
 | Miloš Forman als Father Havel |
 | Holland Taylor als Bonnie Rose |
 | Lisa Edelstein als Ali Decker |
 | Brian George als Paulie Chopra, the Sikh Catholic Muslim with Jewish in-laws who owns an Irish Pub |
 | Rena Sofer als Rachel Rose |
 | Ken Leung als Don |
 | Marilyn Cooper als 'Don't Walk' Lady |
 | Juan Piedrahita als Omar |
 | Bodhi Elfman als Howard the Casanova |
 | Santi Formosa als Basketball Kid #2 |
 | Dagmara Domińczyk als Claire |
| Edward Norton | Producer |
| Stuart Blumberg | Producer |
| Elmer Bernstein | Original Music Composer |
| Avy Kaufman | Casting |
| Malcolm Campbell | Editor |
| Edward Norton | Director |
| Hawk Koch | Producer |
| Anastas N. Michos | Director of Photography |
| Stuart Blumberg | Screenplay |
| Chris Shriver | Art Direction |
| Leslie E. Rollins | Set Decoration |
| Victor DeNicola | Hairstylist |
| Carla White | Makeup Artist |
| Ann Masterson | Makeup Artist |
| Wynn Thomas | Production Design |
| Michael Kaplan | Costume Design |
| Erik Knight | Art Department Coordinator |
| Deirdre Horgan | Script Supervisor |
| Julie Kuehndorf | Unit Publicist |
| Gary Barber | Executive Producer |
| Roger Birnbaum | Executive Producer |
| Jonathan Glickman | Executive Producer |
| Jonathan Filley | Unit Production Manager |
| Mark Cotone | First Assistant Director |
| Stephen Lee Davis | Second Assistant Director |
| Kathy Nelson | Music Supervisor |
| Loren Weeks | Assistant Art Director |
| Brick Mason | Storyboard Artist |
| Michael Stricks | Location Manager |
| Paul Kramer | Assistant Location Manager |
| Mark Carter | Second Second Assistant Director |
| Ellen Gannon | Production Coordinator |
| Roberta J. Holinko | Assistant Set Decoration |
| Christine Moosher | Assistant Set Decoration |
| Joseph Proscia | Leadman |
| John Basile | Set Dresser |
| Peter DeCurtis | Set Dresser |
| Denis Zack | Set Dresser |
| Ken Ferris | Camera Operator |
| Bobby Mancuso | First Assistant Camera |
| Ray Collins | Second Assistant Camera |
| Amanda Hudson | Camera Loader |
| Tom Weston | "B" Camera Operator |
| Peter Masterson | First Assistant "B" Camera |
| Glen Wilson | Still Photographer |
| Daniel Rosenblum | Boom Operator |
| Tommy Louie | Cableman |
| Joel Holland | Video Assist Operator |
| Morris Flam | Gaffer |
| Bill Almeida | Best Boy Electric |
| Ralph G. Crowley | Electrician |
| John G. Velez | Electrician |
| Francis Leach | Electrician |
| Tom Shinn | Electrician |
| Jamie Gallagher | Electrician |
| Clay Liversidge | Rigging Gaffer |
| Tom Prate | Key Grip |
| Kenny Burke | Best Boy Grip |
| Ronald Burke | Dolly Grip |
| John Panuccio | Key Rigging Grip |
| Robert T. Prate | Rigging Grip |
| Steven Blaho | Rigging Grip |
| Ron Stone | Property Master |
| Heather Kane | Assistant Property Master |
| Matilde Valera | Production Accountant |
| Theresa Marsh | Assistant Accountant |
| Penni Smith | Payroll Accountant |
| James A. Brewer | First Assistant Editor |
| J. Paul Huntsman | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Patrick Dodd | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Paul Curtis | Dialogue Editor |
| John C. Stuver | Dialogue Editor |
| Adam Johnston | Sound Effects Editor |
| Christopher S. Aud | Sound Effects Editor |
| David M. Horton | Foley Editor |
| David Horton Jr. | Foley Editor |
| Francesca Dodd | ADR Editor |
| Nancy Nugent | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Dan Scolnik | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Pembrooke Andrews | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Terry Garcia | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Jeff Cranford | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Kevin Bartnof | Foley Artist |
| Casey J. Crabtree | Foley Artist |
| Eric Gotthelf | Foley Mixer |
| Robert J. Litt | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Kevin E. Carpenter | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Michael Herbick | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Raymond M. Samitz | Construction Coordinator |
| Jeffrey L. Glave | Charge Scenic Artist |
| Rita Ogden | Makeup Artist |
| Johnny Villanueva | Hairstylist |
| Jacqueline Payne | Hairstylist |
| Lorraine Z. Calvert | Assistant Costume Designer |
| Tommy Boyer | Wardrobe Supervisor |
| Cheryl Kilbourne-Kimpton | Wardrobe Supervisor |
| Virginia D. Patton | Set Costumer |
| Kate Edwards | Set Costumer |
| Byron Crystal | Extras Casting |
| Beth Bowling | Casting Associate |
| John Ottesen | Special Effects |
| G. A. Aguilar | Stunt Coordinator |
| Keith Siglinger | Stunts |
| Shawnna Thibodeau | Stunts |
| Stephanie Finochio | Stunts |
| Al Cerullo | Pilot |
| Edward O'Donnell | Transportation Captain |
| James Fanning | Transportation Co-Captain |
| Kenneth Karman | Supervising Music Editor |
| Lisa Jaime | Music Editor |
| Kathy Durning | Music Editor |
| Dan Valliere | Color Timer |
| Mary Beth Smith | Negative Cutter |
| Nina Saxon | Title Designer |
| Nora Ephron | Thanks |
| David Fincher | Thanks |
| Jason Vandermer | Additional Camera |
