 | Steve Agee als Gary the Demon |
 | Jon Daly als Terry the Demon |
 | Mary Holland als Miss Lady |
 | Brian Huskey als Mr. Neighbor |
 | Nick Kroll als Photo Joe (voice) |
 | Adrian Rose Leonard als Buddy |
 | Colleen Smith als Donna the Mystic / Floral Handbag |
 | David Theune als Ice Cream Bruce |
| Bill Benz | Director |
| Jesse Falcon | Writer |
| Brian Huskey | Writer |
| Jason Mantzoukas | Writer |
| Rob Corddry | Executive Producer |
| Mark Costa | Executive Producer |
| Jesse Falcon | Executive Producer |
| Brian Huskey | Executive Producer |
| Jason Mantzoukas | Executive Producer |
| Mike Phirman | Music |
| Ali Greer | Editor |
| Kate Crowley | Costume Design |
| Erin Owens | Production Supervisor |
| Chris Palermo | Stunts |
| Paige Boudreaux | Production Manager |
| Krishnaraj Seenivasan | Production Coordinator |
| Carl Herse | Director of Photography |
