 | Zachary Levi als Kurt Warner |
 | Anna Paquin als Brenda Meoni/Brenda Warner |
 | Hayden Zaller als Zack |
 | Ser'Darius Blain als Mike Hudnutt |
 | Dennis Quaid als Dick Vermeil |
 | Chance Kelly als Mike Martz |
| Simeon Castille als Isaac Bruce |
 | Bruce McGill als Jim Foster |
 | Adam Baldwin als Coach Allen |
| Cindy Hogan als Sue Warner |
 | Steven Chester Prince als Gene Warner |
 | Jason Allen Wear als Stadium Security |
 | Aaron J. Brooks als Hy-Vee Customer |
 | Garrett O'Brien als Stadium Security |
| Bryce Bruckbauer als Young Matt Warner |
| Collin Taylor als #87 Ricky Proehl |
 | Beau Hart als Young Kurt Warner |
| Bryce Barfield als Opposing College Head Coach (uncredited) |
| Trisha Zarate als Hy-Vee Cashier |
| Andrew Erwin | Director |
| Jon Erwin | Director |
| David Aaron Cohen | Writer |
| Jon Erwin | Writer |
| Jon Gunn | Writer |
| Brenda Williams | Stand In |
| Mark Ciardi | Producer |
| Sean Devereaux | Executive Producer |
| Kevin Downes | Producer |
| Andrew Erwin | Producer |
| Jon Erwin | Producer |
| Daryl C. Lefever | Producer |
| John Debney | Original Music Composer |
| Kristopher S. Kimlin | Director of Photography |
| Sean Albertson | Editor |
| Andrew Erwin | Editor |
| Nicole Elespuru | Production Design |
| Joseph Nadeau | Art Direction |
| Jennifer Herbel | Set Decoration |
| David Moline | Set Decoration |
| Karyn Wagner | Costume Design |
| Michelle Garbin | Makeup Department Head |
| Hannah Gates | Makeup Artist |
| Sharon Tabb | Makeup Artist |
| Chel Hathaway | Assistant Art Director |
| Sam Howeth | Set Dresser |
| Andy Koyama | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Mathew Waters | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Mathew Waters | Sound Supervisor |
| Sean Devereaux | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| Brian Drewes | Visual Effects Producer |
| Don Libby | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| Greta Ruljevaite | Visual Effects Producer |
| John Allegretti | Visual Effects |
| Tony Young | Executive Producer |
