 | Stephanie Sigman als Sister Charlotte |
 | Talitha Bateman als Janice |
 | Lulu Wilson als Linda |
 | Anthony LaPaglia als Samuel Mullins |
 | Miranda Otto als Esther Mullins |
 | Grace Caroline Currey als Carol |
 | Philippa Coulthard als Nancy |
 | Samara Lee als Annabelle "Bee" Mullins |
 | Tayler Buck als Kate |
 | Lou Lou Safran als Tierney |
 | Brad Greenquist als Victor Palmeri |
 | Mark Bramhall als Father Massey |
 | Joseph Bishara als Annabelle Demon |
 | Alicia Vela-Bailey als Evil Mullins / Demon Hands |
 | Jessie Giacomazzi als Demon Bee (voice) |
 | Adam Bartley als Officer Form |
 | Lotta Losten als Adoption agent |
 | Brian Howe als Mr. Higgins |
 | Kerry O'Malley als Mrs. Higgins |
 | Annabelle Wallis als Mia Form |
 | Ward Horton als John Form |
 | Fred Tatasciore als Demon (voice) |
 | Bonnie Aarons als Demon Nun (uncredited) |
 | Liam James Ramos als Small Boy (uncredited) |
| Tyler A. Johnson als Priest Holding Annabelle (uncredited) |
| Tree O'Toole als Annabelle Higgins (uncredited) |
 | Emily Brobst als Demon Nun (uncredited) |
| David F. Sandberg | Director |
| Gary Dauberman | Writer |
| Dave Neustadter | Executive Producer |
| Walter Hamada | Executive Producer |
| Peter Safran | Producer |
| James Wan | Producer |
| Hans Ritter | Executive Producer |
| Jennifer Spence | Production Design |
| Ando Johnson | Sound Effects Editor |
| Nate Underkuffler | Music Editor |
| Mark Hawker | Special Effects Supervisor |
| Susan L. Bertram | Costume Supervisor |
| Anthony Syracuse | Construction Coordinator |
| Jan McWilliams | Script Supervisor |
| Mitchell S. Drain | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| Adam Kopald | Sound Effects Editor |
| Laura Wiest | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Sean P. Fickert | Key Grip |
| Richard Bullock Jr. | Boom Operator |
| Craig Mann | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Maxime Alexandre | Director of Photography |
| Eleanor Sabaduquia | Makeup Department Head |
| Julie Ann Grasso | Art Department Coordinator |
| Kris Fenske | Sound Effects Editor |
| Lisa Son | Set Decoration |
| Nicki Katz | Casting Assistant |
| Hugo Villasenor | Makeup Artist |
| Michel Aller | Editor |
| Justin M. Lubin | Still Photographer |
| Rich Delia | Casting |
| Leah Butler | Costume Design |
| Thomas Spence | Property Master |
| Adam Boyd | Sound Effects Editor |
| Bill R. Dean | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Jason Garner | Art Direction |
| Mark Norby | Stunt Coordinator |
| Vincent Befi | Assistant Production Coordinator |
| Jules Carideo | Production Coordinator |
| Tree O'Toole | Stunts |
| Jill Stokesberry | Stunts |
| Joel Iwataki | Scoring Mixer |
| Emily Brobst | Stunts |
| Adriana De La Cruz | Set Medic |
| Colby Giovacchini | Set Dresser |
| Charley Stauber | Assistant Sound Editor |
| Chase Keehn | Supervising Dialogue Editor |
| Joe Schiff | Dialogue Editor |
| Chase Keehn | ADR Editor |
| Benjamin Wallfisch | Original Music Composer |
| Richard Brener | Executive Producer |
| Michael Clear | Co-Producer |
| Joshua Throne | Unit Production Manager |
| Cory Johnson | First Assistant Director |
| Cyndi Martin | Second Assistant Director |
| Gary Dauberman | Characters |
| Marilyn Giacomazzi | Stunts |
| Noelle Therese Mulligan | Stunts |
| Michael McGuire | Stunts |
| Laura Merians | "B" Camera Operator |
| Tommy Tieche | "B" Camera Operator |
| BJ McDonnell | "A" Camera Operator |
| Jimmy Ward | First Assistant "A" Camera |
| Nathan Stern | Second Assistant "A" Camera |
| Leigh Rathner | First Assistant "B" Camera |
| Tim Roe | Second Assistant "B" Camera |
| Robert Sharman | Sound Mixer |
| Steven Trapani | First Assistant Editor |
| Bill R. Dean | Sound Designer |
| Alicia Stevenson | Foley Artist |
| Dawn Fintor | Foley Artist |
| Paul Flinchbaugh | Assistant Sound Editor |
| David Jobe | Foley Mixer |
| Thomas J. O'Connell | ADR Mixer |
| Brian Magrum | ADR Mixer |
| Lee Perez-Gonzalez | Production Secretary |
| Michael Feldman | Second Second Assistant Director |
| Taffy Schweickhardt | Production Accountant |
| Lindsey Washington | Payroll Accountant |
| Mike McLaughlin | First Assistant Accountant |
| Mark Gaffney | Assistant Location Manager |
| Michael Chickey | Location Manager |
| Asia Muka | Key Costumer |
| Paula Avazian | Set Costumer |
| Susan Saldutti | Set Costumer |
| Robin Roberts | Costumer |
| Liz Mendoza | Makeup Department Head |
| Jennifer Gerber | Makeup Artist |
| Heide Kacser | Makeup Artist |
| Danielle Noe | Special Effects Makeup Artist |
| Samantha Ward | Special Effects Makeup Artist |
| Kelly Capoccia | Prosthetic Makeup Artist |
| Traci E. Smithe | Hair Department Head |
| Scott Spencer | Chief Lighting Technician |
| Samantha Rosenberg | Hairstylist |
| Yunea Cruz | Hairstylist |
| Donald Fish | Rigging Gaffer |
| Rodney Veto | Best Boy Grip |
| Bob Ivener | Best Boy Grip |
| David Nims | Dolly Grip |
| Ryan Vanlossberg | Dolly Grip |
| Matt Whitted | Grip |
| Mike Mueller | Grip |
| Chris Randle | Grip |
| Chris Goe | Grip |
| Timothy Stuart Hildebrandt | Leadman |
| Matthew Donaldson | Assistant Property Master |
| Thomas Gerhardt | Set Dresser |
| Ryan Patrick Bartley | Set Dresser |
| Danny Metz | Set Dresser |
| Will Mitchell | Set Dresser |
| Cameron Birnie | Set Designer |
| Julia K. Levine | Set Designer |
| Jeremy Burns | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| Joe Love | Special Effects |
| James Ferrera | Unit Publicist |
| Louis Dargenzio | Transportation Coordinator |
| David Christenson | Transportation Captain |
| Nate Bell | Set Medic |
| Tim Williams | Conductor |
| David J. Krystal | Orchestrator |
| John Daro | Digital Intermediate Colorist |
| Pamela Scott-Farr | Digital Intermediate Producer |
| Molly Pabian | Visual Effects |
| Gabriel Vargas | Visual Effects |
| Wing Kwok | Visual Effects |
| Adam Titchenal | Production Assistant |
| Daniel Wehr | Music Sound Design and Processing |
