 | Vincent Price als Locke / Fortunato / Valdemar / Narrator |
 | Peter Lorre als Montresor ("The Black Cat") |
 | Basil Rathbone als Carmichael ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 | Debra Paget als Helene ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 | Maggie Pierce als Lenora ("Morella") |
 | Joyce Jameson als Annabel ("The Black Cat") |
 | Leona Gage als Morella ("Morella") |
 | David Frankham als Dr. James ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 | Lennie Weinrib als Policeman ("The Black Cat") |
 | Wally Campo als Barman Wilkins ("The Black Cat") |
 | Alan DeWitt als Chairman of Wine Society ("The Black Cat") |
| John Hackett als Policeman ("The Black Cat") |
 | Edmund Cobb als Driver ("Morella") |
| Scott Brown als Servant ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
| Benjie Bancroft als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 | Paul Bradley als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| Kenneth Gibson als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 | Kenner G. Kemp als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 | Jack Kenny als Tavern Patron ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| Cosmo Sardo als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| Jack Tornek als Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| Anthony Carras | Editor |
| Pat Dinga | Special Effects |
| Roger Corman | Producer |
| Daniel Haller | Production Design |
| Ray Mercer | Visual Effects |
| Floyd Crosby | Director of Photography |
| Harry Reif | Set Decoration |
| Richard Matheson | Screenplay |
| Les Baxter | Original Music Composer |
| Roger Corman | Director |
| Samuel Z. Arkoff | Executive Producer |
| James H. Nicholson | Executive Producer |
| John Ceniga | Props |
| Lou LaCava | Makeup Artist |
| Ray Forman | Hairstylist |
| Daniel Haller | Art Direction |
| Bartlett A. Carré | Production Manager |
| Al Simms | Music Coordinator |
| Eve Newman | Music Editor |
| Jack Bohrer | Assistant Director |
| Marjorie Corso | Wardrobe Master |
| John L. Bury | Sound |
| Richard M. Rubin | Property Master |
| Ross Hahn | Construction Coordinator |
| Edgar Allan Poe | Short Story |
