 | Christina Ricci als Lizzie Borden |
 | Clea DuVall als Emma Borden |
 | Gregg Henry als Director Attorney Hosea Knowlton |
 | Stephen McHattie als Andrew Borden |
 | Shawn Doyle als Marshall Hilliard |
 | Sara Botsford als Abby Morse Borden |
 | Hannah Anderson als Bridget Sullivan |
 | Andrea Runge als Alice Russell |
 | Billy Campbell als Andrew Jennings |
 | Brett Donahue als Marshal Fleet |
 | Jeremy Akerman als Judge Blaidsell |
 | John Dunsworth als Doctor Bowen |
 | Gary Levert als Judge Coughlin |
 | John Maclaren als Reverend Buck |
 | Andrew Gillies als Judge Mason |
 | Andrew Bush als Medical Examiner |
 | Glen Lefchak als Eli Bence |
 | Brian Downey als Jury Foreman |
| Nick Gomez | Director |
| Stephen T. Kay | Writer |
| Susan Edelman | Casting |
| Tree Adams | Music |
| Henk van Eeghen | Editor |
| James McAteer | Production Design |
| Steve Cosens | Director of Photography |
| Teena Booth | Co-Producer |
| Michael Mahoney | Producer |
| Judith Verno | Executive Producer |
| Cindy Kerber | Associate Producer |
| Randy Boliver | Stunt Coordinator |
| Valerie Halman | Unit Production Manager |
| Marilyn Vance | Costume Design |
| Cendra Martel | Assistant Costume Designer |
| Katherine James | Makeup Department Head |
| Kimberley Spiteri | Key Hair Stylist |
| Ewen Dickson | Art Direction |
| Brian Enman | Set Decoration |
| Jason van Houten | Location Manager |
| Steve Murphy | Transportation Coordinator |
| Forbes MacDonald | Camera Operator |
| Kelsey Smith | Camera Operator |
| Jess MacGillivray | Gaffer |
| Aram Kouyoumdjian | Production Sound Mixer |
| Jeff MacFarlane | Boom Operator |
| Maggie Thomas | Script Supervisor |
| Tina Gerussi | Casting |
| Sheila Lane | Casting |
| Melissa Blakey | Visual Effects Producer |
| Eric Fulford | Visual Effects Producer |
| Douglas Slocum | Assistant Editor |
| Terry O'Bright | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Nick Offord | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Brad Hamilton | Music Editor |
| Gerold Schmidt | Property Master |
| Tara A. Paul | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
