 | Chloë Sevigny als Lizzie Borden |
 | Kim Dickens als Emma Borden |
 | Kristen Stewart als Bridget "Maggie" Sullivan |
 | Jamey Sheridan als Andrew Borden |
 | Fiona Shaw als Abby Borden |
 | Denis O'Hare als John Morse |
 | Jeff Perry als Andrew Jennings |
 | Jody Matzer als Deputy Fleet |
 | Daniel Wachs als Dr. Bowen |
| Roscoe Sandlin als Judge Blaisdell |
 | Darin Cooper als Jury Foreman |
 | Don Henderson Baker als Marshall Hilliard |
 | Laura Whyte als Mrs. Brayton |
 | Tom Thon als Professor Wood |
| Tara Ochs als Susan Gilbert |
 | Jay Huguley als William Moody |
| Katharine Harrington als Matron |
| Vivian Majkowski als New Housemaid |
| Craig Macneill | Director |
| Jeff Russo | Original Music Composer |
| Elizabeth Destro | Producer |
| Naomi Despres | Producer |
| Noah Greenberg | Director of Photography |
| Abbi Jutkowitz | Editor |
| Melizah Anguiano Wheat | Hair Department Head |
| Kate Geller | Casting |
| Chloë Sevigny | Producer |
| Elizabeth Jones | Production Design |
| Stacey Panepinto | Makeup Department Head |
| Bryce Kass | Executive Producer |
| Edward J. Anderson | Executive Producer |
| Carolyn Hunt | Executive Producer |
| Elizabeth Jayne Stillwell | Executive Producer |
| Lynn Appelle | Line Producer |
| Jessica Kelly | Casting |
| Nicole LeBlanc | Art Direction |
| Yann Sobezynski | First Assistant Director |
| Natalie O'Brien | Costume Design |
| Joshua Bachove | Co-Producer |
| Myles Nestel | Executive Producer |
| Kendall Rhodes | Co-Executive Producer |
| James Passanante | Construction Coordinator |
| Amanda Kulkoski | Additional Second Assistant Camera |
| Coy Campbell | Location Assistant |
| Oran Domingue | Location Production Assistant |
| Doug Wright | Transportation Coordinator |
| Jason Crump | Colorist |
| Sally Swisher | Music Editor |
| John 'JR' Craigmile | Post Production Accountant |
| Roxanne Fie Anderson | Executive Producer |
| Eliza Morse | Still Photographer |
| Brandon Babbit | Grip |
| Wendy Moynihan | Assistant Costume Designer |
| J.C. Davis | Key Hair Stylist |
| Emmett Brannen | Set Medic |
| Tom Hardin | Production Accountant |
| Tyson Pixler | Painter |
| Chris Johnson | Steadicam Operator |
| Kate 'Lexi' Vanlandingham | Assistant Chef |
| David Cortes | Assistant Chef |
| Chris 'Barefoot' Allen | Driver |
| Alexander B. Hill | Script Supervisor |
| Chelsea Lockhart | Set Dresser |
| James Johnston | Swing |
| Margaret 'Missy' Hibbard | Art Department Assistant |
| Cory Corbett | Electrician |
| Sheila Ferguson | Seamstress |
| Tori Fields | Additional Hairstylist |
| Mitchell Harper | Location Production Assistant |
| Leroy Williamson | Driver |
| Earl Wilson | Driver |
| Zachary Rowe | Set Medic |
| Jonathan Ferrantelli | Post Production Supervisor |
| Kathryn Sigismund | Visual Effects Coordinator |
| Jay Rubin | Project Manager |
| Lynn Appelle | Unit Production Manager |
| Bob Smith | Leadman |
| Adam Chase | Set Dresser |
| Stephen Cabinum | Best Boy Electrician |
| Kristen Anthony | Key Set Costumer |
| Kara Talley | Key Set Costumer |
| Corey Leon Howard | Key Set Production Assistant |
| Laura 'Trouble' Hayes | Driver |
| Babbett 'Babs' Smith | Driver |
| Marlena Grzaslewicz | Dialogue Editor |
| Ruy García | Supervising Sound Editor |
| Luciano Vignola | ADR Mixer |
| Michael Perfitt | Scoring Mixer |
| Matea Prljevic | Music Editor |
| John Faivre | Propmaker |
| Sue Ruby | Set Decoration Buyer |
| Gregory Gordan | Set Dresser |
| Kyle Perritt | Electrician |
| Asaf Yeger | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| Tierre Turner | Stunt Coordinator |
| Scott A. Lawson | Set Dresser |
| Michael Williamson | Property Master |
| Peter Walts | Gaffer |
| Kristin Morlino | Costume Supervisor |
| Allen Lau | First Assistant Sound Editor |
| Ruy García | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Marie Hunter | Payroll Accountant |
| Teresa Strojny | Painter |
| Kane Pearson | Second Assistant Camera |
| Michael Buster | Dialect Coach |
| Cocoa Rigal | Costume Consultant |
| Dawn Brown | Additional Hairstylist |
| George Watson | Set Production Assistant |
| Cayman Eby | Location Scout |
| Tina Anderson | Driver |
| Marlena Grzaslewicz | ADR Editor |
| Lisa Wilson | Executive Producer |
| Mark Romanelli | Second Assistant Director |
| Marian Green | Stunt Coordinator |
| Genevieve Hawkins | Production Coordinator |
| Marley Mountcastle | Production Secretary |
| Bree Doehring | Production Office Assistant |
| Jeff Berry | Carpenter |
| Jonathan Dossman | Set Dresser |
| Renée Leventis | Assistant Property Master |
| Vivian Majkowski | Dialect Coach |
| Rebecca Hickey | Key Makeup Artist |
| Perrine Virgile | Additional Music |
| Chad Darnell | Extras Casting |
| Aljournal Franklin II | Set Dresser |
| Ebner J. Valdes | Utility Sound |
| Gavin Chin | Dolly Grip |
| Sawyer Oubre | Grip |
| Olivia O'Hara | Set Production Assistant |
| Chris Foster | Sound Effects Editor |
| Bill Higley | ADR Mixer |
| Francis Stone | Painter |
| Wiley Workman | Propmaker |
| Amber Axelton | Set Dresser |
| Jonathan Barrows | Set Dresser |
| Shaquanta Green | Additional Hairstylist |
| James Troutman | Assistant Location Manager |
| Timothy P. Jackson | Driver |
| Adil Mustafa | Driver |
| Nicole Kanoy | Animal Wrangler |
| Bryn Neuenschwander | Project Manager |
| David Lefkowitz | Title Designer |
| Chad Darnell | Local Casting |
| Courtney Fredette | Painter |
| Dean Burns | Set Dresser |
| Lauren Britt | Set Costumer |
| Jody Schiesser | Location Manager |
| Robert Eli Moses | Location Production Assistant |
| Nate Howard | Driver |
| James Willis | Set Medic |
| Amy Doherty | Orchestrator |
| James Sullivan | Painter |
| Jameson T. Meadows | Set Dresser |
| Diana Ardila Gonzalez | Art Department Assistant |
| Richard Lacy | First Assistant Camera |
| Kahlil Fadel | Generator Operator |
| Maria Vaughan | Additional Hairstylist |
| Wendy Armstrong | Catering Head Chef |
| Scott Meekins | Location Production Assistant |
| Shelley A. Fields | Set Medic |
| Nancy Galvan | First Assistant Editor |
| Vico Sharabani | Visual Effects Supervisor |
| John Fitzpatrick Jr. | Greensman |
| James Edward Ferrell Jr. | Set Decoration |
| Alex Richards | Set Dresser |
| Chris Johnson | Camera Operator |
| Connor Williams | Grip |
| Sarah Lawless Emmett | Makeup Artist |
| Randy Southerland | Transportation Captain |
| Michael Perfitt | Score Engineer |
| Bryce Kass | Writer |
| Mark Austin | Propmaker |
| Jim Nelson | On Set Dresser |
| Josh Morton | Additional Camera |
| James Bertis | Boom Operator |
| Dave Knudson | Best Boy Grip |
| Zachary Horrell | Set Production Assistant |
| Charles Baxter | Driver |
| Cindy Kaufman | Set Medic |
| Art Rincones | Set Medic |
| Aleksandra Stojanovic | Foley |
| Anthony Maurella | Set Dresser |
| Christian G. Hawkins | Additional Second Assistant Camera |
| Anton Gold | Production Sound Mixer |
| David Spencer | Key Grip |
| Wendy Geary | Second Second Assistant Director |
| Lucas Gregg | Set Production Assistant |
| Terry Jackson | Driver |
| Richard Manning Hughes II | Set Medic |
| David Fletcher | Special Effects Coordinator |
| Chris White | ADR Mixer |
| Anthony Paderewski | Location Scout |
